2011 Chevrolet Camaro SS

If you're looking for a muscle car, get a muscle car. Go for the big V8 (LS3), manual transmission, with a convertible top. This is the 2SS, so it has all of the bells and whistles.
It's in good shape, but I priced it a little lower than comparable cars so you can put a fresh top on it (doesn't leak, but is looking worn). Fresh oil change, alignment, and I just put in a new power steering pump. Bought the car in Arizona, so it's never tasted road salt.